Monday, August 29, 2011

Mani Shankar Aiyar's false argument

Writing in The Economic Times dated 28th August, M.S.Aiyar argues, "I don't quite know what Anna Hazare is doing at the Ramlila ground when he ought to be laying siege to Dalal Street and the CII headquarters. For, while some of the corruption can be traced to the venality of politicians, all of it leads straight to business houses."

Well, this is a convenient argument to deflect popular anger away from the government. But is this a valid argument? If crimes go unchecked in a particular town, we do not hold demonstration against the criminals. We only question the police / state why they are not taking any effective action. There is an implicit contract between the citizens and the elected representatives who form the government that the latter would keep criminals at bay. There is no agreement between the corporate sector and the citizens that the former would stay away from venal ways. Therefore even if Aiyar's assumption that corporates are the fountainhead of corruption is correct, his conclusion that we should question only the corporates and not the government is absurd.

However if Aiyar is sincere in his expression, we expect him to organise a dharna in front of Dalal Street. We may know how many people support him.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Nativity sets are growing category for gift giving. They are all made of good quality resin and hands painted and capture the true meaning of Christmas for young and old.

10 pc. Nativity set- 590/- INR
12 pc. Nativity set- 1200/- INR
09 pc. Nativity set- 490/- INR
01 pc. Last supper- 950/- INR

For Order Call Now - 9713099668 ( 10 Am to 6 PM)

jesus idol
mother mary pictures